From Living Room Racks to a Thriving Clothing Company: The Story of Modest Molly
In this episode of Her Layered Life, host Amanda Barker sits down with the powerhouse trio behind Modest Molly Boutique — Amanda, Lindsay, and Alyson. What started as a neighborly hobby and a shared need for stylish, modest, and plus-size clothing has grown into a thriving women-owned business that has been serving customers for over eight years.
From splitting their very first clothing order in a living room to running a full-scale boutique with employees and loyal customers nationwide, the women of Modest Molly share the candid story of their beginnings, their roles in the business, and the unexpected lessons learned along the way.
This conversation is full of laughter, honesty, and inspiration for any woman looking to start something of her own — whether it’s a side hustle or a legacy business.
What You’ll Hear in This Episode:
How Modest Molly began with a $500 buy-in and an “accidental” business model.
The challenges (and opportunities) of creating clothing that actually fits and flatters plus-size women.
Why natural role alignment among the founders has been key to their growth.
How their husbands’ skill sets unexpectedly became a foundational layer of support.
Balancing motherhood, family life, and entrepreneurship without losing sight of what matters most.
The importance of loyal customers and how feedback has shaped their collections.
Pivotal moments that shifted the direction of the business — including the decision to focus on plus-size fashion.
About Modest Molly
Modest Molly is a women-owned boutique born out of a simple need: clothes that are trendy, flattering, and size-inclusive. Built on community and friendship, the brand has grown from living-room racks to a beloved shop with a loyal customer base. Their mission is to make every woman feel confident, stylish, and seen.